Beyond The Ballot: What the Elections in Israel Mean for Gaza

SHARE

Israel’s elections are not simply a domestic political event. Their implications extend to Gaza, where the decisions of the next Israeli government could have significant consequences for the territory’s humanitarian situation, political future, and reconstruction prospects. After years of war, destruction, and humanitarian suffering, Gaza’s future remains uncertain. Questions surrounding its governance, the durability of the ceasefire, and the conditions for reconstruction remain unresolved.

As explored in the NCF’s recent article, “Israel’s Long Road to a Government“, the elections have left Israel facing a political deadlock. Although Benjamin Netanyahu remains the caretaker prime minister, Gadi Eisenkot has been tasked by President Isaac Herzog with forming the next government, placing him in a position to potentially replace Netanyahu. Meanwhile, Arab parties have gained significant parliamentary influence, potentially making their support decisive in coalition negotiations. Although the election results do not necessarily signal a shift in Israeli policy towards Gaza, they provide an opportunity to assess the country’s political direction and its potential consequences for Palestinians.

Gaza Between Eisenkot and Netanyahu

Both Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his potential successor Gadi Eisenkot oppose Hamas control of Gaza and insist on its disarmament. However, they differ in their proposed routes towards a post-war arrangement, particularly over the sequencing of reconstruction, Israeli withdrawal, and the establishment of a new administration.

Netanyahu has made the complete disarmament of Hamas and the demilitarization of Gaza preconditions for reconstruction and further Israeli withdrawal. He has rejected proposals to advance these processes before Israel’s demands are met, arguing that reconstruction resources could otherwise enable Hamas to rebuild its military capabilities. By linking Gaza’s recovery to full disarmament, his position has contributed to a prolonged impasse over reconstruction, leaving rebuilding efforts stalled and Palestinians heavily reliant on humanitarian assistance. This has also complicated the implementation of the US-backed Board of Peace, particularly regarding the phased reconstruction plan and a transitional government.

Eisenkot has similarly ruled out Hamas retaining control of Gaza, pledging to end its administration of the territory within 18 months of taking office. However, he has appeared more open to a phased transition under the Board of Peace, involving a technocratic administration and international involvement. His approach suggests that limited reconstruction could begin alongside progress towards Hamas’s disarmament, rather than waiting for the entire process to be completed. Eisenkot has stated that Hamas’s removal could be achieved through diplomatic arrangements or military force, indicating that he is prepared to pursue a political route while maintaining pressure on the group.

A Parliamentary Opening for Gaza?

The increased parliamentary importance of Arab parties could have implications for Gaza beyond the formation of Israel’s next government. If Gadi Eisenkot relies on their support to secure a parliamentary majority, they may have an opportunity to push for changes to the policies governing the territory’s future. Their demands are particularly significant in three areas: ending the war and Israeli military control, allowing reconstruction to proceed, and ensuring Palestinians have a meaningful role in Gaza’s governance.

The Joint List’s platform sets out these demands explicitly. It calls for consolidating the ceasefire, lifting the siege on Gaza, ending Israeli military control, guaranteeing humanitarian aid and reconstruction, and enabling displaced Palestinians to return. It also calls for the resumption of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA) operations and the establishment of an independent Palestinian state. These positions provide a potential basis for parliamentary pressure on Eisenkot to support a more defined path towards Israeli withdrawal and Gaza’s recovery. However, there are significant differences between these demands and Eisenkot’s approach. He has made the dismantling of Hamas’s military and governing capabilities a central condition of his proposed framework for Gaza.

The potential significance for Gaza, therefore, lies in whether Arab parties can make their support conditional on tangible commitments concerning the ceasefire, Israeli military withdrawal, reconstruction, and Palestinian governance. Their increased parliamentary weight creates an opportunity to raise these issues within Israeli politics, but it does not guarantee that Eisenkot will accept their demands or that a coalition agreement will translate into meaningful policy changes.

The Regional Stakes of Israel’s Political Transition

Israel’s election also has implications for the regional countries seeking to advance Gaza’s ceasefire and post-war arrangements, particularly Egypt, Qatar and Turkey. These countries have played central roles in mediating the ceasefire and negotiating the US-backed plan. However, their efforts have been constrained by disagreements with Netanyahu’s government, particularly over the sequencing of Hamas’s disarmament and an Israeli military withdrawal. The three countries have also jointly criticized Israeli strikes for undermining the ceasefire process. A change in Israeli leadership could create greater diplomatic space for these countries to advance the process.

Eisenkot has indicated an interest in improving Israel’s relations with regional powers, viewing cooperation as important to the country’s security and stability. For neighboring countries, a government open to cooperation could create greater scope to coordinate efforts towards Gaza’s recovery. Egypt has indicated that a change in Israeli leadership could create an opportunity to advance the next phase of the ceasefire. Similarly, Turkish officials have indicated that better relations with Israel would depend on progress in easing Gaza’s humanitarian crisis and reducing Israeli military pressure. 

However, greater regional cooperation will not necessarily translate into a change in Israeli policy. While a new government could provide regional actors with a more productive diplomatic channel, meaningful progress for Gaza will ultimately depend on willingness to engage with their proposals and translating them into concrete action.

The Road to Recovery Remains Uncertain

Israel’s new government could create opportunities to move beyond the current impasse over Gaza, but a change in leadership alone will not resolve the challenges facing the territory. Although Eisenkot’s proposed phased approach could offer greater scope for advancing the Board of Peace’s framework, it remains uncertain whether his government would be prepared to make the concessions necessary to implement it. The influence of Arab parties and engagement with regional mediators could help maintain pressure for progress, but neither guarantees a change in Israeli policy.

Ultimately, the future of Gaza will depend on whether the Board of Peace can move from a political framework to meaningful implementation. This requires more than an agreement on Hamas’s disarmament. It requires sustained humanitarian access, an end to Israeli military control, the establishment of a credible Palestinian administration, and the launch of large-scale reconstruction. Without progress on these interconnected issues, the ceasefire risks remaining a temporary pause rather than the beginning of a lasting recovery. Israel’s political transition may create an opportunity to change this trajectory, but its significance will be measured by whether it improves conditions for Palestinians and gives Gaza a viable political and economic future.

Image: Hussein Jaber, CC BY-SA 3.0 IGO, via Wikimedia Commons

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles